Hendersonville, North Carolina, may be known for its apple orchards and Blue Ridge beauty, but when it comes to pizza, this charming mountain town knows how to deliver—literally and figuratively. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or deep dish, New York style or wood-fired Neapolitan, Hendersonville’s pizza scene has something to satisfy every kind of craving.
From local pizzerias with decades of history to trendy new joints experimenting with bold toppings, these are the best pizza places in Hendersonville that are serving up the perfect slices, pies, and everything in between.
1. West First Wood-Fired
A true standout in downtown Hendersonville, West First Wood-Fired combines artisan flair with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. Their pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving the crust a distinctive char and flavor that’s hard to beat. Toppings range from classic margherita to creative combos like pesto, goat cheese, and roasted veggies. Gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese are available too, making it a favorite among foodies and those with dietary preferences alike.
Must Try: The Roasted Pear & Gorgonzola Pizza — a sweet and savory delight.
2. 2 Guys Pizza & Ribs
If you’re looking for hearty, no-nonsense pizza with bold flavors, 2 Guys Pizza & Ribs is the place. Their hand-tossed crust and generous toppings make every pie a filling feast. With more than a dozen specialty pizzas—including the ever-popular Meat Lovers and the tangy BBQ Chicken—you’re sure to leave satisfied. And if you’re feeling adventurous, they also serve ribs and wings that are just as good.
Must Try: The “Everything” Pizza — loaded with meats, veggies, and extra cheese.
3. Pi-Squared Pizza
Bringing a Detroit-style twist to Hendersonville, Pi-Squared Pizza is known for its thick, square crust that’s both crispy and chewy. The edge-to-edge cheese and caramelized crust set it apart from the rest. Each pizza is crafted with care, and you can customize your own or choose from inventive house favorites like “Spicy Italian” or “Chicken Bacon Ranch.”
Must Try: The Motor City Meat Pie — it’s a mouthful of flavor in every bite.
4. Mona Lisa Pizza
A local gem that’s been serving Hendersonville for years, Mona Lisa Pizza is a family-run spot that prides itself on traditional New York-style pizza. Their thin, foldable slices are perfect for eating on the go or savoring slowly with friends. Besides pizza, their menu includes calzones, strombolis, and pasta dishes, making it a great all-around Italian eatery.
Must Try: The White Pizza with ricotta, garlic, and mozzarella.
5. Mezzaluna Brick Oven Tap House
While Mezzaluna is more of a gastropub than a traditional pizzeria, their brick oven pizzas deserve serious attention. With a rustic interior and a great selection of local craft beers, this is the place to go for pizza with atmosphere. Their wood-fired pies feature gourmet ingredients like arugula, truffle oil, prosciutto, and fig jam.
Must Try: The Fig & Prosciutto Pizza — sweet, salty, and unforgettable.
6. Papa’s & Beer (Bonus Mention)
Though it’s known primarily for Mexican cuisine, Papa’s & Beer surprisingly serves up some delicious pizza options, especially if you’re in the mood for a more casual experience. While not traditional, the cheesy, loaded Mexican-style pizzas are a unique take worth trying.
Must Try: The Taco Pizza — a fusion of two comfort food favorites.
Tips for Pizza Lovers Visiting Hendersonville:
- Explore Beyond Downtown: While Main Street has plenty of great spots, some hidden gems can be found just a short drive away.
- Order Local Beers: Many pizzerias here serve local brews from nearby breweries like Southern Appalachian and Guidon Brewing.
- Try Something New: From pear toppings to Detroit-style square pies, don’t be afraid to go beyond pepperoni.
Final Slice
No matter how you slice it, Hendersonville offers an impressive variety of pizza options. Whether you’re dining in at a wood-fired bistro, grabbing a box of cheesy goodness to-go, or discovering a new twist on an old favorite, there’s something for every pizza lover in this cozy mountain town.
So bring your appetite and get ready to explore the best pizza in Hendersonville, NC—one delicious pie at a time.